Andersen Windows vs Home Guard Windows:
Making the Right Choice for Your NJ Home
Finding the right replacement window brand is important if you want to control your home’s comfort, energy usage, and overall value. RJW wants to help homeowners in northern New Jersey look beyond name recognition and focus on what matters most: real-world performance, long-term reliability, and true warranty protection. Comparing brands side by side is the surest way to make an informed investment for your home.
Vinyl vs Composite Window Construction
Home Guard Windows are built using Sunshield virgin vinyl, a material known for its durability and ease of maintenance. Virgin vinyl resists warping, cracking, and fading even in harsh weather. This means less upkeep, no painting required, and consistently smooth operation over the years. Reinforced frames also bolster overall strength.
In comparison, Renewal by Andersen’s Fibrex composite is a blend of reclaimed wood fiber and thermoplastic polymer. Fibrex is recognized for strong resistance to rotting and peeling. Composite frames offer a more rigid structure than basic vinyl but can be heavier and may cost more.
Here’s how these materials stack up in daily use:
Home Guard Vinyl: Easier to maintain, resists weathering, cost-effective, and does not require painting.
Renewal by Andersen Fibrex Composite: Strong, visually appealing, more costly, generally provides good insulation and durability.
Both materials offer lasting performance, but the right choice depends on your project, climate, and budget preferences.
Available Styles, Colors, & Hardware
Home Guard and Renewal by Andersen both provide a wide array of window types and customizable finish options to fit any architectural preference. Home Guard stands out with a broad palette of colors, woodgrain interior finishes, decorative hardware, and grille patterns.
One of Home Guard’s key advantages is FlexScreen integration. This flexible screen technology delivers:
Hassle-free removal and installation for easy cleaning.
Improved airflow while keeping insects out.
Nearly invisible appearance for clearer views.
Renewal by Andersen offers sophisticated hardware packages and finishes as well. However, certain options are only available within select product lines. Both brands make it easy to achieve a tailored look that suits your home.
Glass Technologies & Insulation
Both Home Guard and Renewal by Andersen use Cardinal glass, a trusted name in window glass technology. Cardinal glass is engineered for energy savings, UV filtering, and minimal condensation concerns.
Here are some features to keep in mind when comparing glass performance features:
Argon Gas Fill: Both brands use argon-filled, insulated glass units for strong thermal performance.
Upgrade Opportunities: Energy glass upgrades, including higher-performance coatings and glazing options, are available on each brand to maximize efficiency.
Glass Replacement: If the insulating argon gas is lost or seal failure occurs, both manufacturers have replacement solutions.
Sound Control: Each delivers sound reduction benefits, with the performance varying by the glass type selected.
Selecting the right glass configuration improves both energy efficiency and overall comfort within the home.
Energy Efficiency Comparison
Key energy performance metrics like U-factor and air infiltration make a direct impact on your monthly utility costs.
U-Factor: Measures a window’s heat transfer rate. Lower values mean better insulation.
Air Infiltration: Indicates how much outside air seeps indoors. Lower numbers reflect tighter window construction.
Typical performance varies by product line:
Home Guard Windows often reach U-factors as low as 0.21 to 0.27 and offer strong ratings on air infiltration for their class.
Renewal by Andersen Windows, Fibrex line also posts competitive U-factors within the 0.25 to 0.29 range, with good air infiltration scores.
Both brands are certified by the National Fenestration Rating Council (NFRC). Choosing high-performing replacement windows means potential heating and cooling savings year after year.
Warranty Coverage
A warranty defines the kind of long-term security you get from your new windows. Home Guard Windows provide a lifetime, transferable warranty, including glass breakage coverage and protection against frame and sash issues. This warranty stays with your home if you sell, maximizing resale value and reducing possible out-of-pocket repair costs.
Renewal by Andersen’s limited warranty varies by product line. Fibrex composite frames include lengthy, though more restrictive, coverage for materials and workmanship, with separate protections for hardware and insulated glass.
Value & Total Cost of Ownership
Price is only part of the equation. To find the true cost of ownership, you have to consider how well your windows will perform and protect you from future expenses.
Home Guard Windows deliver strong value with lower upfront costs, high material longevity, and a comprehensive lifetime warranty to limit future costs.
Renewal by Andersen Windows features a respected brand and advanced composites, typically at a higher initial investment, with segmented warranty terms.
When you weigh warranty, durability, and actual maintenance demands, Home Guard Windows consistently stand out as a cost-effective, long-term option for New Jersey homeowners.
Why Homeowners Trust RJW Exteriors for Replacement Windows
RJW Exteriors is the exclusive local installer for Home Guard Windows. Home Guard partners with only the most qualified contractors committed to quality workmanship and integrity.
For over 30 years, RJW Exteriors has worked with families across our region to deliver reliable window replacement solutions. We are fully licensed and insured, and every crew member is guided by a commitment to award-winning customer service. As a trusted, veteran-owned local business, our reputation matters to us, so we value transparency and collaboration.
Learn about the quality work our values produce in our customer reviews and project spotlight gallery.
Request a Window Consultation for your New Jersey Home
RJW Exteriors is ready to help you decide if Home Guard Windows are right for your home. Contact us to schedule your personalized, no-obligation consultation. If you are considering ways to manage your investment, financing is available for qualified buyers. Explore your options on our financing page.
Proudly Serving Northern New Jersey Communities
Mon-Thu: 8am - 8pm
Fri: 8am - 5pm
Sat: 8:30am - 4:30pm
Sun: Closed